| 2024-25 (Super Bowl LIX) |
Jalen Hurts Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback |
| 2023-24 (Super Bowl LVII) |
Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs Quarterback |
| 2022-23 (Super Bowl LVII) |
| Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs Quarterback |
| 2021-22 (Super Bowl LVI) |
Cooper Kupp Los Angeles Rams Wide Receiver |
| 2020-21 (Super Bowl LV) |
Tom Brady Tampa Bay Buccaneers Quarterback |
| 2019-20 (Super Bowl LIV) |
| Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs Quarterback |
| 2018-19 (Super Bowl LIII) |
Julian Edelman New England Patriots Wide Receiver |
| 2017-18 (Super Bowl LII) |
| Nick Foles Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback |
| 2016-17 (Super Bowl LI) |
| Tom Brady New England Patriots Quarterback |
| 2015-16 (Super Bowl 50) |
Von Miller Denver Broncos Linebacker |
| 2014-15 (Super Bowl XLIX) |
| Tom Brady New England Patriots Quarterback |
| 2013-14 (Super Bowl XLVIII) |
Malcolm Smith Seattle Seahawks Linebacker |
| 2012-13 (Super Bowl XLVII) |
Joe Flacco Baltimore Ravens Quarterback |
| 2011-12 (Super Bowl XLVI) |
Eli Manning New York Giants Quarterback |
| 2010-11 (Super Bowl XLV) |
Aaron Rodgers Green Bay Packers Quarterback |
| 2009-10 (Super Bowl XLIV) |
Drew Brees New Orleans Saints Quarterback |
| 2008-09 (Super Bowl XLIII) |
Santonio Holmes Pittsburgh Steelers Wide Receiver |
| 2007-08 (Super Bowl XLII) |
| Eli Manning New York Giants Quarterback |
| 2006-07 (Super Bowl XLI) |
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Quarterback |
| 2005-06 (Super Bowl XL) |
| Hines Ward Pittsburgh Steelers Wide Receiver |
| 2004-05 (Super Bowl XXXIX) |
| Deion Branch New England Patriots Wide Receiver |
| 2003-04 (Super Bowl XXXVIII) |
| Tom Brady New England Patriots Quarterback |
| 2002-03 (Super Bowl XXXVII) |
| Dexter Jackson Tampa Bay Buccaneers Safety |
| 2001-02 (Super Bowl XXXVI) |
| Tom Brady New England Patriots Quarterback |
| 2000-01 (Super Bowl XXXV) |
| Ray Lewis Baltimore Ravens Linebacker |
| 1999-00 (Super Bowl XXXIV) |
Kurt Warner St Louis Rams Quarterback |
| 1998-99 (Super Bowl XXXIII) |
| John Elway Denver Broncos Quarterback |
| 1997-98 (Super Bowl XXXII) |
| Terrell Davis Denver Broncos Running Back |
| 1996-97 (Super Bowl XXXI) |
| Desmond Howard Green Bay Packers Kick Returner |
| 1995-96 (Super Bowl XXX) |
Larry Brown Dallas Cowboys Cornerback |
| 1994-95 (Super Bowl XXIX) |
Steve Young San Francisco 49ers Quarterback |
| 1993-94 (Super Bowl XXVIII) |
| Emmitt Smith Dallas Cowboys Running Back |
| 1992-93 (Super Bowl XXVII) |
| Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys Quarterback |
| 1991-92 (Super Bowl XXVI) |
Mark Rypien Washington Redskins Quarterback |
| 1990-91 (Super Bowl XXV) |
| Ottis Anderson New York Giants Running Back |
| 1989-90 (Super Bowl XXIV) |
| Joe Montana San Francisco 49ers Quarterback |
| 1988-89 (Super Bowl XXIII) |
| Jerry Rice San Francisco 49ers Wide Receiver |
| 1987-88 (Super Bowl XXII) |
| Doug Williams Washington Redskins Quarterback |
| 1986-87 (Super Bowl XXI) |
| Phil Simms New York Giants Quarterback |
| 1985-86 (Super Bowl XX) |
Richard Dent Chicago Bears Defensive End |
| 1984-85 (Super Bowl XIX) |
| Joe Montana San Francisco 49ers Quarterback |
| 1983-84 (Super Bowl XVIII) |
Marcus Allen Los Angeles Raiders Running Back |
| 1982-83 (Super Bowl XVII) |
| John Riggins Washington Redskins Running Back |
| 1981-82 (Super Bowl XVI) |
| Joe Montana San Francisco 49ers Quarterback |
| 1980-81 (Super Bowl XV) |
| Jim Plunkett Oakland Raiders Quarterback |
| 1979-80 (Super Bowl XIV) |
| Terry Bradshaw Pittsburgh Steelers Quarterback |
| 1978-79 (Super Bowl XIII) |
| Terry Bradshaw Pittsburgh Steelers Quarterback |
| 1977-78 (Super Bowl XII) |
| Harvey Martin & Randy White Dallas Cowboys Defensive End/Defensive Tackle |
| 1976-77 (Super Bowl XI) |
| Fred Biletnikoff Oakland Raiders Wide Receiver |
| 1975-76 (Super Bowl X) |
| Lynn Swann Pittsburgh Steelers Wide Receiver |
| 1974-75 (Super Bowl IX) |
| Franco Harris Pittsburgh Steelers Running Back |
| 1973-74 (Super Bowl VIII) |
Larry Csonka Miami Dolphins Running Back |
| 1972-73 (Super Bowl VII) |
| Jake Scott Miami Dolphins Safety |
| 1971-72 (Super Bowl VI) |
| Roger Staubach Dallas Cowboys Quarterback |
| 1970-71 (Super Bowl V) |
| Chuck Howley Dallas Cowboys Linebacker |
| 1969-70 (Super Bowl IV) |
| Len Dawson Kansas City Chiefs Quarterback |
| 1968-69 (Super Bowl III) |
Joe Namath New York Jets Quarterback |
| 1967-68 (Super Bowl II) |
| Bart Starr Green Bay Packers Quarterback |
| 1966-67 (Super Bowl I) |
| Bart Starr Green Bay Packers Quarterback |